Key Principle
Partial discharge in an MCC insulator or tracking on a contaminated busbar support generates high-frequency sound in the 20–100 kHz range. An ultrasound survey of the closed MCC panel through ventilation openings detects this before the discharge is visible, before it produces a detectable thermal signature, and long before it escalates to arcing.
What Ultrasound Detects in MCCs
Airborne ultrasound detection works on a straightforward physical principle: electrical discharge activity, whether corona, tracking, or arcing, produces turbulence at frequencies above human hearing (typically 20 kHz to 100 kHz). A calibrated ultrasound detector converts those frequencies into audible sound and a dBµV reading that can be logged and trended.
Inside a low-voltage MCC, the mechanisms that generate ultrasound include:
Corona Discharge
Corona forms at conductors, edges, or fittings where the local electric field exceeds the ionization threshold of the surrounding air. In low-voltage MCCs (below 600V), corona is uncommon under normal conditions, but it can develop at sharp edges on damaged busbar, at conductor tips not properly insulated, or at surface contamination on insulators that concentrates the field. The acoustic signature is a relatively steady hiss or crackling at the detector.
Surface Tracking
Contamination on insulator surfaces creates conductive pathways for leakage current. Oil mist, dust, condensation, and carbon deposits from prior arcing events all contribute. As leakage current flows across the contaminated surface, it produces intermittent electrical discharge that generates ultrasound. Tracking is a progressive degradation mechanism: the discharge itself heats and carbonizes the surface, which makes the conductive path more conductive, which increases discharge intensity. An early-stage tracking signature sounds like irregular crackling, becoming louder and more sustained as the track develops.
Arcing
Active arcing produces a loud, irregular burst signature distinctly different from the steady hiss of corona. A loose connection making intermittent contact, a failing contactor with welded contacts, or tracking that has progressed to intermittent arcing all produce this signature. Any arcing detected in an MCC is an immediate finding. Arcing can propagate to arc flash within seconds if conditions are right.
Loose Connections (Acoustic Emission)
Loose electrical connections under load can produce ultrasound through the vibration of conductors and the micro-sparking at intermittent contact points. This signature is more irregular than corona and does not have the consistent frequency pattern of tracking. It can be difficult to distinguish from arcing in its early stages, which is why any irregular burst signature warrants immediate investigation.
Survey Procedure Without Opening Panels
The primary advantage of ultrasound for MCC surveys is that it works through closed panels. Surveys can be conducted without opening doors, without establishing an arc flash boundary, and without requiring electrical workers in full arc flash PPE to be present throughout the survey.
Instrument Setup
Set the detector to 40 kHz for general MCC surveys. This frequency provides a good balance between sensitivity to electrical discharge activity and rejection of mechanical noise sources (motors, fans, pumps) that produce acoustic emissions primarily below 20 kHz. Some practitioners use a frequency sweep to confirm findings, but 40 kHz is the standard starting point for electrical panel surveys.
Use a focused probe (also called a parabolic reflector or rubber cone probe) to isolate the signal from specific panel openings. A scanning probe or rubber tip alone picks up signals from a wide area and makes it harder to localize the source.
Establishing a Background Reading
Before surveying the MCC, take a baseline reading in the open space away from the equipment. This is your facility background dBµV level. Readings at the MCC panels are compared against this background, not against an absolute number. The threshold for investigation is typically 12 dBµV above background, though some facilities establish their own thresholds based on historical survey data.
Survey Sequence
- Begin at the top of each MCC section, working systematically downward
- Hold the probe at or near each ventilation opening, cable entry point, or gap in the panel door
- Hold for 3 to 5 seconds at each position and note the peak dBµV reading and audio character
- Log the reading for each section: section identifier, probe position, dBµV reading, audio description
- Flag any position reading more than 12 dBµV above facility background for further investigation
- Flag immediately any position producing irregular burst or arcing-type audio character, regardless of dBµV level
Work around the full perimeter of each MCC section. Signals can propagate through the panel enclosure from an internal source, so a single high reading may require probing from multiple points to triangulate the location.
Comparing Sections
Within the same MCC row, compare sections with similar circuit loading. A section driving three 100 hp motors will naturally show higher background acoustic levels than a section with small control circuits. Valid comparison requires similar load conditions. Where loads vary significantly, rely on the audio character of the signal rather than absolute dBµV comparisons to distinguish electrical discharge from load-related mechanical noise.
Audio Signatures and Their Meaning
| Audio Character | Probable Source | Urgency |
|---|---|---|
| Steady hiss or frying sound | Corona discharge at conductor or insulator edge | Investigate; schedule inspection within 30 days |
| Irregular crackling, increasing over time | Surface tracking on contaminated insulator or busbar support | Priority; inspect within 7 days; trend weekly |
| Loud, irregular bursts | Intermittent arcing at connection or across surface | Immediate; stop survey, notify electrical supervisor |
| Regular clicking at power frequency | Loose or vibrating mechanical component, or contactor chatter | Investigate; may be mechanical rather than electrical |
| Low-level steady hiss, uniform across section | Normal operating noise from contactors, transformers | No action; log as baseline |
The audio character carries as much information as the dBµV reading. A reading of 15 dBµV above background with a steady hiss is a different finding than 15 dBµV above background with burst-type arcing sounds. Document both the number and the description.
When to Open for Investigation
Two conditions trigger an internal inspection after a closed-panel ultrasound survey:
- Any reading more than 12 dBµV above the facility-established background level, confirmed by repositioning the probe to verify the reading is repeatable and not an artifact
- Any audio character consistent with arcing, regardless of the dBµV reading
Opening an MCC panel for investigation requires establishing an arc flash boundary, appropriate PPE, and an energized work permit per NFPA 70E. The ultrasound survey has already identified the specific section of concern, which focuses the internal inspection and reduces the duration of exposure.
If the audio or dBµV reading is severe enough to suggest active arcing, consider de-energizing the affected section before opening. An active arc flash incident during panel opening is the scenario the survey is designed to prevent.
Partial Discharge Detection in Medium-Voltage MCCs
Medium-voltage motor control centers (above 600V, typically 2.4 kV to 15 kV) introduce additional failure mechanisms that require specific PD detection methods alongside airborne ultrasound.
UHF Sensors
Partial discharge in medium-voltage equipment emits electromagnetic energy in the UHF range (300 MHz to 3 GHz). UHF sensors mounted on or near the MCC panel detect this emission through small coupling slots or ventilation openings. UHF detection is sensitive to PD events that may not yet be producing audible ultrasound, making it an earlier warning indicator for medium-voltage insulation degradation.
Transient Earth Voltage (TEV) Sensors
Partial discharge within a metal-enclosed switchgear or MCC panel causes transient voltage pulses on the panel exterior. TEV sensors placed on the panel surface detect these pulses in the 3 MHz to 100 MHz range. TEV is a fast, non-intrusive screening method: a handheld TEV probe touched to the panel exterior gives an immediate indication of whether PD is present inside. High TEV readings prompt further investigation with airborne ultrasound or UHF sensors to characterize the source.
Airborne Ultrasound at Ventilation Points
Medium-voltage MCC enclosures are typically sealed more tightly than low-voltage MCCs, but ventilation openings at the top and bottom of each section provide survey access points. Probe these at 40 kHz using the same technique as for low-voltage equipment. PD in medium-voltage equipment tends to produce stronger ultrasound signals than in low-voltage equipment because the discharge energy is higher.
For medium-voltage MCCs, it is common to use all three methods in combination: TEV for rapid screening, airborne ultrasound for audio characterization and localization, and UHF for early detection of incipient PD that is not yet strong enough to produce a clear ultrasound signature.
Integrating Ultrasound with Thermal Surveys
Thermal surveys and ultrasound surveys detect different failure mechanisms. Together they cover the two primary electrical degradation pathways in MCCs.
| Failure Mechanism | Primary Driver | Detection Method |
|---|---|---|
| Resistive heating at loose or corroded connections | Current (I²R heating) | Infrared thermography |
| Corona discharge at high field stress points | Voltage (field intensity) | Ultrasound / UHF |
| Surface tracking on contaminated insulators | Voltage + contamination | Ultrasound (early); Thermal (late) |
| Intermittent arcing at deteriorated connections | Current + voltage | Ultrasound (audio signature); Thermal (secondary) |
| Insulation degradation in medium-voltage equipment | Voltage (dielectric stress) | UHF PD sensors; TEV |
The key practical point is sequencing. Ultrasound finds electrostatic discharge (voltage-driven) early, often before any thermal signature is detectable. Thermal surveys find resistive heating (current-driven) once the temperature differential is large enough to measure. A facility that runs only one method is blind to one of the two major failure pathways.
The recommended survey sequence for an MCC inspection interval is: ultrasound first (closed panel, faster, lower risk), then thermal (doors open or through ventilation slats, PPE required). Ultrasound findings that indicate a specific internal location focus the thermal survey on that area.
Where ultrasound indicates PD at an insulator and the thermal survey shows no corresponding hotspot, the finding is early-stage: the discharge has not yet produced enough sustained current to generate detectable heat. This is the detection window that provides time for planned maintenance before the failure progresses.
Documentation Requirements
Ultrasound survey records need to capture enough information to support trending across multiple survey intervals and to write specific corrective maintenance work orders.
For each survey position, record:
- MCC designation, section, and probe position (e.g. "Section 3B, top ventilation slot, left side")
- Detector model and frequency setting (typically 40 kHz)
- dBµV reading (peak reading at that position)
- Facility background dBµV at the time of the survey
- Delta above background
- Audio character description (hiss, crackling, burst, clicking)
- Photograph of probe position from exterior
- Date and time of survey
- Load conditions in affected sections
For positions with no anomaly, a brief "surveyed, no anomaly detected" note with the dBµV reading and background is sufficient. This confirms the position was surveyed.
When a finding triggers an internal inspection, document the inspection findings and the repair separately, then schedule a follow-up ultrasound survey at the next maintenance opportunity to confirm that the repaired area is no longer producing an elevated signal.
Detect Partial Discharge Continuously
Periodic surveys find conditions between inspections. Continuous monitoring sensors detect discharge activity as it develops, correlate electrical and acoustic data, and alert maintenance teams before the failure window closes.
See Electrical Monitoring