ESA

How to Implement Electrical Signature Analysis

A practical guide to setting up an ESA program: sensor requirements, measurement procedure, baseline collection, and how to interpret results.

Key Difference

ESA requires one additional measurement compared to MCSA: a voltage probe at the motor terminals alongside the current clamp. That second sensor turns a current-only snapshot into a simultaneous voltage and current record that enables negative-sequence analysis and supply-vs-motor fault separation.

Hardware Requirements

A complete ESA measurement setup requires sensors on all three phases for both current and voltage. Missing a phase means the negative-sequence calculation is unavailable, which is precisely where ESA's diagnostic advantage over MCSA lies.

Current clamps

Install a current clamp on each of the three phase conductors feeding the motor. Clamp placement is typically at the MCC or motor starter, downstream of any protective device. The clamp must be rated for the motor's full-load current with headroom for startup inrush. Flexible Rogowski coils are practical where rigid clamps cannot fit around conductors in crowded cable trays.

Voltage probes

Voltage measurement must be taken at the motor terminal block or MCC supply terminals, not at the utility supply upstream. The reason: supply-side imbalance and motor-side winding asymmetry both produce a negative-sequence voltage component, but they are spatially separated. Measuring at the motor terminals captures both contributions simultaneously, which is what the analysis needs to separate them.

Do not use utility metering points or the main switchboard bus as a voltage reference for ESA. The cable run between the utility measurement point and the motor terminals introduces its own impedance and can mask or misattribute small imbalances.

Data recorder

The recorder must support simultaneous three-phase voltage and current acquisition. Sequential sampling, where the device switches between channels, will introduce phase timing errors that corrupt the negative-sequence calculation. Required specification:

Measurement Procedure

Load condition is the single most important variable in ESA. Many fault signatures, particularly negative-sequence components associated with winding asymmetry, scale with load. Measurements taken at low or no load are unreliable for comparison against baselines recorded at higher load.

Pre-measurement checklist

Recording

Capture simultaneously for a minimum of 2 to 4 seconds at stable load. Longer records (10 to 30 seconds) improve frequency resolution in the spectral analysis and reduce noise in harmonic amplitude estimates. For motors running on VFDs, the minimum record length depends on the fundamental output frequency selected by the drive; consult the analyser documentation for VFD-specific requirements.

What to log alongside the waveform

Each measurement record should be stored with a metadata header that includes:

Without this metadata, trending across measurements taken weeks or months apart is unreliable. A rising I2/I1 ratio is only meaningful if load and temperature at each measurement are known and comparable.

Baseline Collection

The first measurement determines all future comparisons. A baseline recorded on a degraded motor will hide real deterioration for months until the fault progresses far enough to exceed the contaminated reference.

When to take the baseline

Take the baseline measurement on a motor confirmed as healthy: immediately after commissioning, immediately after a rewind or major rebuild, or after a full inspection that confirmed the stator and rotor are in good condition. Do not take a baseline on a motor that has been running without inspection for an unknown period.

What to record as the baseline state

At minimum, record these quantities from the baseline measurement and store them against the asset ID:

These four quantities are the reference state. All future measurements are evaluated as delta from this baseline, not as absolute values against generic limits from a textbook.

Interpreting Results

The most common interpretation error is acting on a single measurement in isolation. ESA results are meaningful as trends across multiple measurements at consistent load conditions. A single elevated I2/I1 reading could reflect supply imbalance on that day, not motor deterioration.

Negative-sequence component I2/I1

If I2/I1 rises consistently across successive measurements taken at comparable load, this indicates growing winding asymmetry in the motor. The rise is the signal, not the absolute value. A motor with I2/I1 of 3% at baseline showing 7% on the third measurement is more concerning than a motor that has been stable at 6% across ten measurements.

Before attributing a rising I2/I1 to the motor, measure supply voltage imbalance (V2/V1) at the same time. Supply imbalance drives current imbalance in a predictable ratio. Separate what the supply is contributing from what the motor itself is generating. If V2/V1 has also risen, address the supply first before concluding the motor has deteriorated.

Harmonic content

Rising harmonic content in the current spectrum can indicate stator winding changes (partial shorted turns introduce specific harmonic frequencies) or supply-side distortion. Cross-reference with supply voltage harmonic content measured simultaneously. If supply THD is stable and current THD is rising, the source is in the motor.

Fault separation protocol

  1. Measure supply voltage imbalance (V2/V1) first
  2. Calculate the expected current imbalance contribution from supply imbalance alone, using the motor's negative-sequence impedance ratio
  3. Subtract the supply contribution from the measured I2/I1
  4. The residual is the motor's own contribution to current imbalance

This separation is the diagnostic step that MCSA cannot perform. MCSA sees the combined effect; ESA sees them individually.

Periodic vs Continuous ESA

Periodic ESA uses a portable analyser carried to each motor on a scheduled interval. Continuous ESA installs permanently mounted voltage transformers (VTs) and current transducers (CTs) at the motor terminals, with the data streamed to a monitoring platform that computes ESA metrics continuously.

Periodic measurement

Practical for assets where a quarterly or monthly visit is sufficient given the expected fault progression rate. The technician connects the portable analyser, records 4 to 10 seconds of simultaneous V and I data, and the software computes I2/I1 and harmonic content on the spot or on upload. The limitation is the same as any periodic program: faults that initiate and progress within the measurement interval are missed until the next visit.

Continuous monitoring

Permanently installed VTs and CTs feed real-time data to a monitoring platform. The platform computes I2/I1, harmonic content, and supply imbalance continuously and raises alarms when trends cross thresholds relative to the stored baseline. No technician visit is required for each data point. The alarm response time is minutes rather than weeks.

Continuous ESA is most justified on motors where the fault consequence (unplanned downtime cost, safety risk, or production impact) exceeds the hardware installation cost within one or two avoided failures.

Program Scope: Which Motors Justify ESA

Not every motor in a facility needs ESA. The analysis is most valuable where the combination of fault risk and fault consequence is high.

High-priority candidates

Lower-priority assets

Small motors below 15 kW with immediate redundancy and low rewind cost are generally better served by run-to-failure or basic MCSA. The cost and complexity of full ESA instrumentation is not proportionate to the replacement cost or downtime exposure.

Continuous ESA with Tractian

Tractian's condition monitoring platform captures simultaneous three-phase voltage and current continuously, computes I2/I1 and harmonic content automatically, and alerts when trends cross baseline thresholds.

See Electrical Monitoring
electricalmonitoring.com is an independent educational resource covering electrical motor monitoring technologies.
Content is produced by Tractian. References to third-party technologies are for informational purposes only.